Talk about your boneheaded political decisions. Last week, Republicans in the Senate pulled the trigger on the "nuclear option," changing Senate rules to eliminate the filibuster. And why did they exercise such an extreme option? To make it possible to confirm Donald Trump's first pick for the Supreme Court, Neal Gorsuch, with a simple majority vote, despite staunch Democratic opposition. The Republicans won this round. They got their guy. But one wonders if Senate leadership really sat down and thought this all the way through. Their victory is a hollow one, at best. Yes, they got their guy. But I believe they will come to regret "going nuclear" in the long term.
The problem with "going nuclear" is that it has far-reaching and permanent implications. Right now, the GOP is assuming -- rather arrogantly, I think -- that they will ALWAYS have control of the Senate and the House of Representatives. History has shown this not to be the case. At some point, probably in the not-too-distant future the way things are going, Democrats will regain control of Congress and the White House. And what happens when they do? What happens the next time there's an opening on the Supreme Court and the Democrats nominate someone the GOP finds objectionable? By "going nuclear," the GOP will have eliminated its own ability to stop the nomination, or even to really mount a challenge. Talk about "cutting off your nose to spite your face." By ?going nuclear," r Republicans have, in effect, neutered the system of checks and balances that is designed to weed out unqualified or undeserving nominees. This isn't the way the system is supposed to work.
And for whom did they take such a radical step? They did all this for Neal Gorsuch, a judge who is certainly qualified, but who is also undeserving of this lifetime appointment. We're talking about a judge who has routinely ruled against workers' interests in favor of big corporations. In his most famous case, he ruled against a trucker who was fired after choosing to save his own life instead of freezing to death. That not only shows a serious lack of good judgment, but a lack of basic human decency and compassion. Is this really someone we want sitting on the nation's highest court, possibly for decades?
The decision to exercise the "nuclear option," in addition to being incredibly short-sighted, also exposes one of the key symptoms of what is wrong with our political systtem today -- the inability, or unwillingness, to compromise. Members of the Senate might have worked this out if they were willing to move off dead center and actually meet in the middle somewhere. They might have worked this out if they had take n their responsibility seriously and actually considered Gorsuch based strictly on his qualifications. But, no. Republicans were so anxious to "stick it" to Democrats and get their way that they "went nuclear" without considering the long-term implications of that action. There's no denying they won this round. But there's no doubt that they will ultimately come to regret taking such an ill-advised action.
Sunday, April 9, 2017
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)